Chemical Composition of Commonly Used Local and Foreign Steel Reinforcements and the Effects on the Strength Property of the Material Composites

Document Type: Research Note

Authors

1 Department of Civil Engineering, University of Abuja, Abuja, Nigeria

2 Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Lagos, Akoka, Lagos, Nigeria

Abstract

In recent times, structural failure of buildings and civil infrastructures are on the increase in developing countries. These failures can be attributed to the use of; poor material, influx of quacks, unethical professional practices, poor construction methodology and the use of unverified newly introduced reinforcements. This study investigated the chemical contents of commonly used new local steel reinforcements and imported steel reinforcements as to the level of compliance with ASTM A 706  and BS 4449 specifications. The effects of the percentage composition on the strength properties of the material and consequential effects on concrete composite were discussed. Chemical analyses of local bars revealed higher sulphur and phosphorus contents which increased brittleness though with enhanced strength. The higher contents of minor elements like silicon, Manganese, Chromium, Zinc in local steel specimens increased loss of mass in aqueous solutions and in water compared with the foreign specimens. In conclusion, while the imported bars satisfied the ASTM and BS standards in terms of the percentage composition of the elements, local bars did not meet these standards. Hence, it is recommended that the development of National Building Codes that reflect the actual material characteristics to avert premature failure for concrete structures reinforced with the local bars.

Keywords


[1]     Amobi CO. Pro-active measures to avoid failures and collapse of buildings in Nigeria. J Niger Inst Build 2006;13:25–9.
[2]     Arum C, Babatola JO. Failure of Building Structures, Causes an Preventive Measures. Proc Tech Sess Annu Eng Week Niger Soc Eng Akure 2006:50–61.
[3]     Ayininuola GM, Olalusi OO. Assessment of Building Failures in Nigeria: Lagos and Ibadan Case Study’. African J Sci Technol 2004;5.
[4]     Olusola BA, Opawole A. Causes of building failure in Nigeria. J Build Apprais 2009;4:279–86.
[5]     Kolade OO. Characterization of steel reinforcement bars in the Nigerian markets and performance evaluation in concrete structures, M. Eng thesis, unpublished report submitted to Department of Civil Engineering, Federal University of Agriculture Abeokuta, Nigeria 2014.
[6]     British Standards Institution, Code of Practice for Structural Use of Concrete. BS 8110: Part 1, London, British Standards Institution 2004.
[7]     Kareem B. Quality verification of made in Nigeria steel bars. J Sci Tech Res 2006;5:33–6.
[8]     Nwabuokei SO. “The Nigerian Steel Industry: Delta Steel Company Experience,” A paper presented at the Annual Lecture of the School of Engineering and Engineering Technology, FederalUniversity of Technology, Akure 2007.
[9]     Kareem B. Tensile and chemical analyses of selected steel bars produced in Nigeria. Aust J Technol 2009;13:29–33.
[10]   https://collegegrad.com/industries/steel-manufacturing (2019) n.d.
[11]   British Standards Institution, Structural use of steelwork in building code of practice for design –rolled and welded sections, BS 5950, Part 2. London, British Standards Institution, 2001. n.d.
[12]   British Standards Institution, Specification for cold reduced steel wire for the reinforcement of concrete. BS 4482, London, British Standards Institution, 1985. n.d.
[13]   Singh B, Kaushik SK. Influence of steel-making processes on the quality of reinforcement. Indian Concr J 2002;76:407–12.
[14]   Topçu IB, Karakurt C. Properties of reinforced concrete steel rebars exposed to high temperatures. Res Lett Mater Sci 2008;2008.
[15]   Timoshenko SP, Gere JM. Mechanics of Materials, PWS Publishing Company, London 1997.
[16]   Ede AN, Egunjobi EO, Bamigboye G, Ogundeji J. Assessment of quality of steel reinforcing bars used in Lagos, Nigeria. Int Res J Innov Eng 2015;1.
[17]   Rocha J de L, Pereira R dos S, de Oliveira MCL, Antunes RA. Investigation on the relationship between the surface chemistry and the corrosion resistance of Electrochemically Nitrided AISI 304 stainless steel. Int J Corros 2019;2019.
[18]   Foley RT. Role of the chloride ion in iron corrosion 2013.
[19]   American Society for Testing and Materials, Specifications for chemical contents of steel fibres, ASTM A 706/A706 M, 2013 n.d.
[20]   Nautiyal A, Qiao M, Cook JE, Zhang X, Huang T-S. High performance polypyrrole coating for corrosion protection and biocidal applications. Appl Surf Sci 2018;427:922–30. doi:10.1016/j.apsusc.2017.08.093.
[21]   British Standards Institutions, BS 4449, Carbon Steel Bars for the Reinforcement of concrete” London, pp.1- 17, 1997. n.d.
[22]   Nigerian Standard, NST 65-M, Raw Materials and Specifications for Federal Government Steel Companies, 1st Ed. Ministry of Power and Steel. NST- 65 - Mn, 1994. n.d.
[23]   Kankam CK, Adom-Asamoah M. Strength and ductility characteristics of reinforcing steel bars milled from scrap metals. Mater Des 2002;23:537–45. doi:10.1016/S0261-3069(02)00028-6.
[24]   Basu PC, Shyiamoni P, Roshan AD. Characterisation of steel reinforcement for RC structures: An overview and related issues. Indian Concr J 2004;78:19–30.